The Greater Cleveland Partnership
with help from its subsidiary the
Downtown Cleveland Alliance works
very hard to keep those nasty
panhandlers off the street in the
front of the old Higbee’s building.
That was not the case
last Thursday.
In fact, our
community’s biggest Moochers were on
full display at Higbee’s, before an
attentive news media, as Squire,
Sanders & Dempsey Managing Partner
Fred Nance tried mightily to peddle
a medical mart and convention center
to be built on Forest City land
costing $40 million. Thanks,
Uncle Sam (Miller). From the
coverage I’ve seen, Nance must have
done a hell of a job, Brownie.
The news media were peddling his
wares for him.
The Partnership paid
for the study selecting the Tower
City site. The Partnership
does not come with clean hands.
The price of the deal
– financed almost totally with
public funds – had jumped from $400
million to $526 million.
(What a bonanza for
those who want to give contracts
to friends. This makes the
allegedly criminal house
enticements for Jimmy Dimora and
Frank Russo just petty and stupid,
damaging to the community but not
as ruinous as the Nance deal.)
In other words,
they’ve already added $126 million
to a deal that in total would have
cost at least $1 billion anyway.
It will now cost more than $1
billion dollars for this essentially
unnecessary construction. How do I
figure that?
Just as easily as
Nance’s smooth explanation of why
this is a good deal for all
taxpayers of Cuyahoga County.
The cost is $526
million to be financed by the
quarter-percent sales tax added by
Commissioners Tim Hagan, Jimmy
Dimora and Peter Lawson Jones
without a vote by the public.
(Jones didn’t vote for it because
they didn’t need his vote but he’s
for it now. The same goes for
his November opponent Bay Village
Republican Mayor Deborah Sutherland
whose dodgy advice is to be
“extremely careful” with the deal,
but she is not opposed to the
project.)
That $526 million
will not appear magically.
Cuyahoga County will have to borrow
the money (most of it - $461 million
- needed quickly for construction).
With interest until 2027 - duration
of the bonds - we will have paid
likely double - or nearly double -
the $526 million.
There’s your Billion
dollars, folks.
Added to that, the
County will pay MMPI (Merchandise
Mart Properties, Inc.) $103 million
to operate the convention center.
Nance made a big thing of MMPI,
unlike Gateway, taking on cost
overruns and capital expenses but
didn’t mention the $103 million
taxpayers will pay. Nor did he
allow for any changes in structuring
the deal as were common at Gateway
to the public’s greatly added cost.
Nance asked Wachovia
Investment managing director of
finance Tim Offtermatt, also a
Gateway financial expert, to the
podium to testify to the
interest-earning power of County
bonds. Offtermatt did.
But I asked Offtermatt whether
County bonds also had to PAY
interest and wouldn’t it about
double the cost of the project?
“Quite likely,”
Offtermatt said.
I asked him, “How
much are the bonds going to cost?”
He responded, “Who knows.” I
then said, “Well, you know what
the interest is going to be on the
income (from bond money before its
expenditure on construction).”
Nance quickly
pulled Offtermatt from the podium.
“Why can’t the financial guy
respond? He knows the
numbers,” I said to Nance.
Nance had other
ideas. He compared the bonding of
this project to buying a house. You
don’t say the house cost the selling
price plus the interest paid over
years, he said.
“But this isn’t a
house,“ I told him. “It does
mean you are expending a billion
dollars of public money, aren’t
you? Aren’t you?”
Nance said that
that was “over 20 years.”
It is still one
billion dollars in public money.
Nance was a bit
testy. He immediately tried
to suppress questioning by
cautioning about “time.” I
told him that he had spent a lot
of time telling us what he wanted
to talk about, now it was our
turn.
And get this.
I asked Nance how many floors of
the Higbee building - site of the
"city-saving" medical mart - will
MMPI utilize? His answer:
Two floors. Two floors?
Yes, “part of the first floor,”
now occupied by The Partnership,
and a basement area, some occupied
by theaters. Nance also
didn’t know of the asbestos
situation in the Higbee's
building.
Two floors? Then
where is all this businesses from
medical sources going to be?
They’ve been telling us a medical
mart is the medicine that is going
to bring us gobs of money and, of
course, JOBS. All on two
floors?
The County will pay
only $1 for the Higbee's MMPI site.
However, taxpayers will pay to
construct the offices for the
medical mart & MMPI.
This deal that Nance
and The Partnership is offering is
much, much worse than anyone could
have thought, especially in tough
economic times..
Are there no
community needs more urgent for such
massive public subsidies?
And get this - The
Partnership and Nance want an
increase in the bed tax of 2
percent. That will bring in
another $50 million of public funds
to be used for the two-floor medical
mart. The Partnership and
Nance also want $2.5 million a year
of the present bed tax to be
diverted to the project, adding
another $50 million over 20 years.
Nance said County Commissioners have
“statutory” right to raise this tax
without a public vote. Oh, boy, one
more dodge around County voters!
Who says you can’t
squeeze blood from a turnip?
Nance and The Partnership can always
squeeze more money for their private
needs.
Could our
suffering Greater Cleveland Regional
Transit Authority (RTA), now cutting
services that now are more needed
than ever, use these public monies?
You bet.
Meanwhile, your sale
tax “contribution” is piling up in
the County cashbox. That may
be true for years before
construction starts.
Nance already said
that the tax will bring in more
money. Of course it will
continue to rise, as prices of
everything rise, so do your sales
taxes, a continually expanding
public “contribution.”
Nance gave great
emphasis to the “connectivity” of
this site. He meant that the
convention center will be connected
to Tower City, to the Ritz (owned by
Sam & the boys) and Renaissance
hotels, to retail (also owned by
Forest City) and the airport via
RTA.
But what about the
“connectivity” of The Partnership,
Cleveland’s corporate leadership
(can we really use that word?) and
the Forest City Crowd – Sam Miller
and Al Ratner and families.
What about the
“connectivity” of Hagan defending
and sending former county
administrator Dennis Madden – under
sexual harassment embarrassment – to
MMPI. Connected, ah yes.
Doesn’t this shift of Madden suggest
the same old Commissioner’s game of
playing politics in the worse
corrupting sense?
What about the
“connectivity” of the hypocritical
Hagan – he who seeps arrogance from
every pore – with MMPI’s president
Christopher Kennedy, son of Robert
Kennedy, and the very close family
ties of Hagan and the Kennedys.
And get this, Nance –
huckstering all the way – actually
crowed about the committee’s make-up
– all members of The Partnership!
I almost burst out
laughing as he praised members,
including David Daberko, killer of
National City Bank, and Henry Meyer,
slayer of Key Bank. We need to
take advice from these guys?
The Partnership didn’t include a
single public official. How
fraudulent can the process here
become?
And how glowing could
salesman Nance be?
“We
are very happy to report that we
are very pleased with our
recommendation… and very confident
and comfortable with the results,”
he told news people.
Well, la-di-da.
I’d be happy and
pleased, comfortable and confident,
too, if I were Fred Nance, Managing
Partner of Squires, Sanders &
Dempsey.
You know which law
firm will be handling the bond issue
for the County? You can take
this to the bank – Squire, Sanders &
Dempsey, the same law firm that’s
handling the business for the County
and The Partnership now.
Indeed, Nance told me so.
Wonder if the FBI or The Plain
Dealer might be interested in
this “connectivity” of this conflict
of interest?
County Commissioners
have already guaranteed to pay up to
$175,000 to Nance for his convention
center work.
Is there
“connectivity” between this fee and
his leading the chorus for The
Partnership? No, conflict of
interest, huh?
Some back scratching
is acceptable. Some is not.
Now here’s
“connectivity” par excellence.
Nance must have had this on his mind
as he came up with the
“connectivity” doctrine.
What is also
disturbing as hell is that once
again the entire massive tax bill is
being picked up by residents and
taxpayers of Cuyahoga County.
Where is the
regionalism in paying off these
massive projects? The area’s
major projects – Gateway, Browns
Stadium, and now the medical mart
and new convention center – are all
financed on the backs or out of the
pockets of Cuyahoga County and
Cleveland taxpayers.
The rest of the
region pays nothing.
Thanks, Hagan, Dimora
and Jones. Thanks Nance,
Daberko, Meyer and The Partnership.
(Joe Roman – The
Partnership’s $426,000 a year
leader remained in the back of the
room during the press conference.
He could never do the smooth job
Nance performed on the media.)
One of the major
reasons The Partnership, Nance said,
rejected the Mall and present site
of the city’s convention center for
the new project was the issue of
water level.
I also asked Nance,
as a principal in the construction
of the Browns Stadium, what the
water level had been there since it
was much closer to Lake Erie than
the present convention center.
Nance punted. Water levels
differ by location, he said.
So you can build a
massive stadium, fill it with more
than 70,000 people (many overweight,
I believe) on land nearer to Lake
Erie but in the vicinity of the old
convention center site, further
inland, the water level won’t
support building.
The chosen water site
at the Cuyahoga River – and
conveniently owned by the Miller-Ratner
gang and connected to its real
estate center – has no water problem
for a new expensive convention
center apparently. It has been
studied, said Nance.
Nance said that the
project would include 925 parking
spaces. Not much and
suggestive to me that we (the
taxpayers) will be building another
freebie garage. Nance
also mentioned that it would be nice
to have a new hotel, too.
Columbus, for example, has 3,000
parking spaces at its convention
center. He also seemed to brag
that 60 percent of the exhibit area
would have 45 feet in
height.
That’s good, but the IX Center goes
45 to 77 feet. What happens to
the IX, city property, not to
mention the old convention center?
The PD, which went
whole hog on the County corruption
issue, has been hiding on this
matter. It’s coverage is
deadly dull, deadly irrelevant and
deadly wide of the mark.
And so it is for this
city, which Forbes magazine
last week placed in its list of top
ten of the "America's Fastest Dying
Cities." Maybe not dying fast.
Certainly it is a city on life
support because of the
self-interested decisions of its
business leadership.
Cleveland needs
urgent care that it won’t get at any
medical mart.