Ah, how we miss you.
Still.
The Cleveland Press,
circa 1982.
The Press often had
better street creds than The Plain Dealer did. It was more the
working stiff’s paper, open a bit more to
dissenting views.
This year will mark the
25th anniversary of the death – or murder – of the Cleveland Press. It
left the Plain Dealer a newspaper monopoly. It deprived the PD (and its
readers) of healthy competition.
Point of View
newsletter revealed the first real evidence the Cleveland Press’ death six
months before the afternoon newspaper folded.
In the early 1980s, I
would spend many Friday afternoons – when news sources had escaped for the
weekend – at the Cuyahoga County Recorder’s offices.
I would search the
recent filings of legal documents, typically new business partnerships, formed
for this or that venture. It usually proved rewarding, as it did in the
case of the Press.
I found evidence of
troublesome Cleveland business and political relationships. I think Milt
Widder and Bill Dvorak, who wrote interesting gossip columns at the Press,
must have had a source at the Recorder’s office. It seems a good bet
that they got tips from someone there for rare gossip column items.
These searches led to a
number of juicy political items. One revealed George
Forbes in business with landfill mogul Pete Boyas and another, Jim Carney, a
Cleveland Democratic Party boss and city power broker, a partner with Forbes.
A number of connections showed up in business and political figures in
partnership to vie for the city’s cable franchise.
These rarely examined
legal filings tipped the business associations of other political and business
movers and shakers.
Sometime at the end of
December 1981, I came across evidence filed for a land deal. It foretold
the end of the Press.
The deed had been filed
quietly at the Recorder’s office.
Though it involved a
newspaper, there was no mention of the real estate transfer in either
newspaper – Press or Plain Dealer.
“When any 103-year old
institution disappears, it’s heartbreaking. When a daily, living
connection to everyday people dies, it’s tragic,” I’ve written of the
newspaper’s death.
The legal papers filed
that December acknowledged the transfer of the land upon which the Cleveland
Press stood to a private partnership headed by Press owner Joe Cole. He
had purchased the Press from Scripps-Howard. The Cleveland paper had
been the flagship of the famed newspaper chain.
I wrote about the land
deal in the Jan. 30, 1982 issue of Point of View. It started:
“Cleveland Press
owner-publisher Joseph Cole has said that the reason he wanted to save the
city’s second newspaper was that he wanted to repay the people of Cleveland
for his success as a millionaire businessman here.
“The more cynical among
us said that Cole wanted a valuable piece of property in downtown Cleveland
to make more money.
“In fact, Cole
recently announced that he wanted to
develop land adjacent to the Press newspaper building as an office-hotel
complex. A $128-million project
was announced with fanfare.
“Those interested in
preserving at least a two-newspaper city reasoned that the dying
Press could possibly be revived with income from an office building, a
subsidy to the lack of income from the paper.
“But a series of real
estate changes in the Press property in December suggests that the more
cynical might have been right.
“That the reasoning
that Cole has less interest in paying back the city and citizens of
Cleveland and preserving a second newspaper and more interest in fattening
his wallet, might be correct.
“Cole has had the real
estate property – land and building – of the Press Publishing Company, which
he heads, transferred to a limited partnership in which he holds controlling
interest.
“The changes in the
ownership of the Press real estate holdings suggest that the profits from
any real estate development would not go toward subsidizing a losing
newspaper but to a limited partnership controlled and benefiting Cole.
“The Press Publishing
Co., owned by Cole, sold the property and building at the corner of East 9th
Street and Lakeside Avenue to Lakeside Associates.
“Lakeside Associates,
formed the same day as the property transfer, has two limited partners
named: Joe Cole and James P. Malone, Jr.
“Documents filed with
Cuyahoga County say that Cole owns two-thirds and Maloney one-third.
“The Partnership,
according to the filing, was organized 'to acquire certain real estate
property and improvements situated at E. 9th Street and Lakeside and to own,
lease, rent, mortgage, improve, repair, sell, convey and otherwise deal
with such real property and improvements.'”
It was the death knell
of the Press.
I ran across the
information by chance.
Today, two office
structures sit on the formidable foundation
where
the newspaper presses once stood. (More about the Death of the Press in
future columns.)
I ended the January 1982
article... “The outlook for the Press isn’t bright and the real estate
deal suggests that Cole got the main asset out of the newspaper’s ownership –
a warning and a message of his real concern.”